Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Buffalo Chicken Tender
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Spaghetti & 3 Meatballs
Pierogis' W/Bacon & Onions
About
Waterford Pizza And More
Welcome to Waterford Pizza And More, a culinary haven located at 208 High St, Waterford, PA 16441. If you’ve been on a quest for exceptional pizza and Italian dishes in Erie County, your search ends here. As someone who has explored numerous eateries, I can confidently say that Waterford Pizza And More stands out in a league of its own, thanks to its dedication to quality and flavor.
At the heart of this establishment lies the pizza—crafted with love and precision. Customer experiences speak volumes, with one thrilled patron, Adam, praising the crust for its perfect balance and the rich sauce that tantalizes the taste buds. The moment you take a bite, you can appreciate the carefully selected ingredients—each adding to a flavorful explosion that keeps you coming back for more. It's easy to see why so many have declared it the best pizza they've enjoyed since relocating to Waterford.
But there's more to savor at Waterford Pizza And More. The menu boasts an array of mouthwatering options, including their famed calzones, which have delighted guests like Renee. She raves about the crispy exterior and generous fillings, emphasizing the restaurant's knack for creating comfort food that satisfies both the stomach and the soul. Guests also remember their experiences fondly—like Red Beard, who chose Waterford Pizza for a retirement party and was blown away by the service and flavorful food, leaving little behind for leftovers!
The atmosphere at Waterford Pizza And More is just as inviting. The friendly staff fosters a warm, welcoming vibe, which enhances your dining experience. Whether you are placing a takeout order or dining in, you will feel the pride that resonates in the food and the service. Like Oberyn Viper noted during his first visit, the warmth extends to the staff with their genuine friendliness, making your meal feel like a treasured occasion rather than just another dinner.
As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I cannot stress enough the importance of supporting local businesses like this one. Indeed, Waterford Pizza And More has become a gem in the community, where every bite reflects traditional craftsmanship mixed with contemporary flair. So, if you’re in the area, do yourself a favor and skip the chain restaurants. Visit Waterford Pizza And More for pizza and Italian dishes that are not only delicious but made with love. You may just find your new favorite spot, like so many others have!
For inquiries, you can reach them at +1 814-796-0200. Don't wait; indulge in the delightful flavors that await you at Waterford Pizza And More!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ As a recent transplant from Philadelphia, I've struggled to find pizza in Erie County that lives up to the incredible quality I was used to back home—until now. Last week, I ordered from Waterford Pizza and More for my staff, and we were all blown away. This is hands-down the best pizza I've had since moving here—hot, fresh, and absolutely bursting with flavor. The crust is perfectly balanced—not too thick, not too thin—the sauce is rich and savory, and the cheese is top-notch. On top of that, the staff is incredibly friendly, and the store has a warm, welcoming vibe that captures the charm of Waterford. You can feel the pride they put into their food and their service. I’ve already been telling all my friends and family—this place is a must-try. Do yourself a favor: skip the chain spots and support this amazing local gem. I’ll be coming back again and again! ”
“ The best Calzone so yummy and crispy outside lots of feelings inside Just the way I like it!!! ”
“ I grew up in Erie, PA. Luchettis was my favorite pizza growing up. They haven't been open for quite a while. I now live in Ohio and it was hard finding pizza that tastes so good. I found it with Waterford Pizza. Best tasting pizza I've had in a long, long time. Thank you! Delicious!! ”
“ Had Waterford pizza cater my father's retirement party and let me say by far thee best service and food!!! Everything was delicious and there was hardly any food left after the party!! Highly recommend to others and also will be using them in the future!! Thanks Waterford Pizza!!!! ”
“ Stopped by Saturday for the first time. Put in an order for 2 chicken bacon ranch calzones. We ordered 2 mediums expecting them to be a little on the smaller side. Boy were we wrong, these things are massive! And they were packed with bacon, chicken and cheese! The blonde gentleman in the back was very friendly too. ”
“ We love the pizza, steak and chicken salads, apps are also fantastic!! Stromboli is next on our list!!! ”
“ Jordan made my veggie pizza and it was the best pizza I think I ever had! He also had great customer service skills while he was taking my order, will definitely be back! ”
“ Decided to get a philly calzone on the way to the Fair last night and was pleasantly surprised. One of the best calzones I've had served by a team of three well groomed smart young ladies. Hope y'all keep sending out great food !! ”